Why does the Church instruct that women cannot be ordained when Jesus said, “Verily, I say to you, whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven”?
The power to bind and loose do not mean the pope and bishops can do whatever they want. The expression delegates to forbidding or allowing sure things in relation to the commandments, but this does not apply to the actual commandments themselves. For example, the commandment is to keep holy the Sabbath. The specific things that are allowed or forbidden on the Sabbath are part of the power to bind and loose, but the commandment itself cannot be done away.
The binding and loosing are delegating to church laws, not divine laws. The difference between the two is so great that canon law refers to church laws as “merely ecclesiastical law” (can. 11). The Church is clear that its teachings on consecration come from divine law and not “mere” Church law.
Did you find this content helpful? Kindly tell us what you think.